Jackson Olson Earns Judges’ Praise With Foxtrot on Dancing With the Stars
- Jackson Olson scored 18 out of 30 with a foxtrot to Gracie Abrams’ “That’s So True” on Dancing With the Stars season 35’s Viral Hits Night.
- All three judges pointed to real growth from his cha cha premiere the week before, with Carrie Ann Inaba calling it a big improvement.
- Chef Giada De Laurentiis went home after scoring 12, while three couples tied atop the leaderboard at 21 points apiece.
A Second Baseman Finds His Footing in the Ballroom
Jackson Olson stood at the center of the dance floor in a black suit, waiting for the first notes of Gracie Abrams’ “That’s So True,” and thought less about the cameras than about second base back at Historic Grayson Stadium. The Savannah Bananas infielder and his partner, Emma Slater, moved through a foxtrot that earned him 18 points out of a possible 30 on Tuesday’s episode of Dancing With the Stars, a jump from his cha cha debut the week before.
Judge Carrie Ann Inaba called out the growth right away, telling Olson she saw “a big improvement from last week” and pointing to the chemistry building between him and Slater. Derek Hough said he came away impressed by how Olson carried his posture and arms through the routine, calling the technical side of his dancing solid and telling him it keeps building week to week. Bruno Tonioli, never shy with a compliment, described the whole three minutes as charmed.
Where the Score Landed on Viral Hits Night
Eighteen points put Olson in the middle of a fourteen-couple field on a night built around songs that defined the last year of social media feeds, reworked into ballroom arrangements the judges had never heard performed live before. Three couples tied for the top score of the night at 21 points: Olympic figure skater Amber Glenn with partner Pasha Pashkov, Paralympic sprinter Ezra Frech with Daniella Karagach, and actress Jenna Dewan with Val Chmerkovskiy.
At the other end of the leaderboard, celebrity chef Giada De Laurentiis scored a 12 for her routine and was sent home at the end of the episode, the second elimination of the season. Olson’s score kept him clear of the bottom tier by six points, a gap the judges suggested has room to grow if his technical work keeps pace with his stage presence.
From Grayson Stadium to a Ballroom Floor
Olson plays second base for the Savannah Bananas, the flagship club of the six-team Banana Ball Championship League, and built a following among Banana Ball fans well before ABC came calling. He opened his run on the show the week before with a cha cha to the Spice Girls’ “Wannabe,” a routine that leaned into the same showmanship fans already knew from his between-innings act in Banana Ball. Hough called that first performance the work of a natural born entertainer, and the judges have now watched him carry that energy into two very different styles of dance in as many weeks.
The jump from infield to ballroom floor is not the leap it looks like on paper. Banana Ball asks its players to sing, dance and run choreographed bits with teammates between innings as part of the format’s built-in entertainment, and Olson built a reputation doing exactly that through the 2026 season. Pairing him with Slater, a two-time champion on the show, puts him with a coach who has turned athletes with no formal dance training into real contenders before, something Bananas fans who watched Olson’s between-innings routines all summer will recognize in how quickly he has picked up two full styles.
Athletes Have a Mixed Record on This Floor
Professional athletes have gone both ways on Dancing With the Stars over the show’s run. Some, like retired NFL players and Olympic gymnasts with years of conditioning and body control behind them, have gone on to win the mirror ball trophy outright. Others struggled to translate raw athleticism into the specific footwork and posture ballroom dancing demands, and left the competition within the first few weeks. Olson’s early scores put him closer to the middle of that history than either extreme, a contestant picking up technique fast enough to avoid the bottom of the leaderboard without yet challenging for the top.
Bananas fans watching from home have reacted online in the days after the episode aired, comparing notes on his scores against teammates who have taken their own turns in front of a national television audience this year. The team’s social accounts reposted clips of the foxtrot within hours of the broadcast, treating Olson’s run on the show as an extension of the same publicity machine that has carried Banana Ball from a single stadium in Georgia to seventy-five ballparks across forty-five states this season.
A Storyline Running Alongside the Playoff Race
For Banana Ball fans, Olson’s run on the show has become its own storyline, playing out at the same time as the league’s playoff race. The Bananas close their regular season this weekend in Arlington against the Texas Tailgaters at Globe Life Field, and Olson has kept up that stretch of the schedule alongside weekly rehearsals and a live broadcast three time zones from most of his teammates. Whether that workload starts to show in his scores could become clear as the competition moves past its opening weeks, when eliminations start coming every round instead of every other.
Dancing With the Stars moves into its third week with the field down to thirteen couples after De Laurentiis’s elimination. The show had not announced next week’s theme as of Wednesday, though past seasons have used the early weeks to test contestants across contrasting styles before settling into music tied to a specific decade or genre. Olson and Slater sit outside the top tier of scores but ahead of the bottom of the field, a position that gives them a real path to climb if the growth the judges keep pointing to continues week to week.